I am obsessed with black eyeliners, and this was reviewed as being the blackest black you can get. Also, the fact that it was matte was alluring. I definitely love the color and pigment of the eye shadow, but it smudged a tiny bit more than the previous two eyeliners. It stays soft for blending for about 30 seconds before drying and staying all day, so if you are a fan of the smoky eye- this is an ideal eyeliner for you! My only complaint is that it is a REALLY soft pencil so you have to sharpen it frequently, and it did not sharpen evenly for me. Just a little pet peeve! Any thoughts on Urban Decay?
Disclaimer: I am not a beauty guru, makeup expert, circus clown in training, or anything of the like. I am not reviewing these products for any reason other than sharing my experience with my faithful readers. Hope you enjoy! Feedback welcome.